This film tells the story of a perfect world. Everyone here is happy. When Jonas is 18 years old, he's chosen to be the community's Receiver of Memories. He enters into training with an old man called The Giver. From the Giver, Jonas learns about pain, sadness, war, and all the unhappy truths of the "real" world. He quickly realizes that his community is fake. Confronted with this reality, Jonas faces difficult choices about his own life and his future.
Brenton Thwaites : Jonas
Jeff Bridges : The Giver
Meryl Streep : Chief Elder
Everything is connected.
Everything is balance.
Where there is good, there is bad.
Can you imagine yourself a world without colors? A dull society where everyone is equal because some social values were smoothed and human emotions such as joy, passion, wonder, lust and love were banished. All this to ensure that conflicts won’t arise anymore. This seems to me quite frightening. Of course, this also provides a number of positive benefits, such as the non-existence of hatred, revenge, jealousy and imperious feelings. Everything for a conflict-free and serene society. A kind of bungalow-park in the clouds where everyone apologizes all the time for everything and nothing (“We accept your apology.“)
It al starts gray.
And that’s how “The Giver” begins. In slight nondescript gray tones. For those who just start watching this movie without knowing anything about it, here’s a warning. Don’t check the color settings of your TV. There’s nothing wrong with it. It’s a colorless society where all the survivors live after the big disaster, which they call “The Ruin”. It’s an unexplained global disaster that ensured that the earthlings now live in a sort of commune. A commune where everyone obediently gets their medication injected every morning, so that they are protected from all those obnoxious human traits which lead to catastrophes.
This society also gives you an Orwellian feeling. At the slightest wrong move or contact, an almost ethereal voice begins to admonish you. And as certain irregularities may happen, even a holographic projection of one of the elderly could suddenly appear in the middle of your kitchen. A peaceful society where the inhabitants are pampered in the superlative and walk through life like meek lambs.
The Receiver lives in full color.
Memories are also erased, so no one can make an association with the old human values. The complete human history, up to the time of “The Ruin”, is unknown to all residents. Except for “The Receiver of Memories”. This chosen person has only one mission. And that’s to cherish all these memories and memorize them in case they are needed in certain circumstances.
Jonas (Brenton Thwaites) is a carefree teenager who gets to hear during the “Release to elsewhere” ceremony, a ritual in which the teenagers of a certain age are assigned tasks that they will perform all their lives, that he’s assigned to this high function. And so he’s being taught by the former “Receiver” (Jeff Bridges) who hands over his former memories and feelings just by physical contact. And so the former “Receiver” automatically gets the function as “The Giver”. In this way Jonas experiences what it’s like to live in a colorful world. He witnesses pleasant feelings such as love, joy and happiness. And also human tragedies and the associated unpleasant feelings such as pain, loss and grief.
Yet another book adaptation.
“The Giver” is yet another adaptation of a book in which we are introduced to a dystopian world. We have seen this already in “Elysium“, “The Hunger Games” and recently “Divergent“. An unknown apocalypse recreated earth in an inhospitable place where the survivors have rallied in a kind of commune where new values and standards are introduced.
The book served as the basis for this movie, is a bestseller from 1993 written by Philip Noyce. As in “Divergent” youngsters get assigned their task of life at a certain age. In “Divergent” they can choose for this function. And in all these films, there is a coordinating organization who is running the show and of course a young person who is special in a way and is the cause for profound changes in the system. Probably everything will be as before again, so society is doomed to relapse into its original destructive habits.
An emotionless society. Yeak!
Overall, I liked “The Giver“. It’s an enjoyable film and at some level even better than its predecessors. Brenton Thwaites plays the youthful innocence convincingly and the metamorphosis from a numb jaded person into a rebellious teen is beautifully executed. The general atmosphere and presentation of this future society was worked out beautifully. Even Jeff Bridges could fascinate me (more than in “R.I.P.D.“), although he sometimes sounded like a poorly lubricated lawnmower. The policies adopted in this seemingly conflict-free society and the way in which it was controlled, made me shiver with horror.
In principle, the elimination of all the listed characteristics, made sure that no one is better or feels more than any other. And the hunger for power is non-existent. But ultimately the elderly are still superior and define the guidelines in this commune. Who determines that all these people are being spied on and an intervention is needed when someone forgets to take his daily suppressive medication or looks with a lascivious glance at someone of the opposite sex? And even though feelings are suppressed, I found it a bit perplexing to see that birth control or the elimination of members of a multiple birth, after determining who is the strongest, was performed in such a cruel and inhumane way. Even the most callous and apathetic person realizes what he’s doing.
Too bad there’s no tension in it.
The biggest letdown was the lack or total absence of any tension. The tension is as flat and colorless as the images used in the run-up of the story. And of course, there had to be a bit of romance in it. The strongest elements were the interaction between “The Receiver” and “The Giver.” Fascinating, full of character and original. But for me, the biggest asset is the fact that we probably won’t get a series of consecutive episodes. As an isolated movie “The Giver” is anything but a bad movie. It only drowns in a tangle of similar dystopian films. The approach is original, but the overall picture isn’t. And probably the book is way better than the film.